Dear Mrs. Zrihen,
I have read PUNISHED! By: David Lubar, which is a new author to me. My favorite quote is on chapter 1 page one paragraph one “This is a terrible idea” I liked it because I thought the book was going to start with the mystery, I was wrong but I still liked it. My favorite part of the book was when Logan was PUNISHED.
This book is about a boy named Logan who is hardheaded and silly with help from his best friend Benedict. Benedict wants to be student of the month so bad because you get a coupon for a free pizza from the best pizzeria in town that he decides to do his school report the same day it is assigned thinking it will get him in good with his teacher Mr. Vernack. Therefore, he drags Logan (who already won the award two months ago and is saving the coupon for the perfect day) to the library to get started on the report. However, as soon as they get there, Benedict tags Logan who cannot resist a good game of tag, so he runs after Benedict. Then, he bumps into a middle-aged man Logan says sorry, but the man thinks he is irresponsible and he should be punished. Logan, now scared sees the old man take out a dust old book and blows it in Logan in face, then disappears. Logan meets up with Benedict and heres how the conversation goes “cut it out! You almost got me in trouble!” (Logan says) “Sorry” (Benedict says) “will you please try to behave your shelf?” “What?” “Behave yourself”. Then he goes home and meets his mom, “did you find everything you needed?” (Mom) “Yup eyebrows the books all the time to see what’s new “(Logan) “I browse the books the books all the time too. I really enjoy it” “ Alphabet you do” “ I’ll bet I do too” “ I don’t see what’s so punny.” “very punny”. Logan’s punishment is everything he says for the rest of his life will come out as a pun! So has soon as he comes home from school the next day he goes to the library and meets the man and asks him how he can undo the punishment. He gives Logan a camera that can only take pictures of oxymoron’s he has one day to find seven oxymoron’s. After he gets the oxymoron’s the man gives him a bag that only sucks in anagrams so, Logan has to get seven anagrams. After that he gives him rubber bands that only rap around palindromes so, he has to get seven palindromes and the punishment is lifted.
I used six strategies in total while reading this book, two before, two during, and two after. Two during are: 1) I read the title and I thought it would be an interesting book 2) I skimmed and scanned the book to see the authors order of organization (chronological order). Two during: 1) I would summarize after each chapter. 2) depending on what the chapter was about I would predict what the next chapter will be about. Two after: 1) I thought about the main idea of the book 2)I discussed it with my mom.
The Protagonists were: Logan, Mom, Dad, Kaylee, Benedict, and Professor Robert Wordsworh,. The Antagonists were: Benedict, Professor Robert Wordsworh, and
Mr. Vernack .
The genre of this book is Mystery the sub genres are: fantasy and educational. The tone and mood were Mysterious. The moral was never play in the library (lame, right?) (but the book wasn’t lame). P.O.O was in chronological order. The P.O.V was in first person (Logans). The author’s purpose was to entertain and educate. The figurative language was oxymoron’s , anagrams, and palindroms.
I recommend this book to students who like to read a good mystery and learn something new ages 10-14.
I would rate this book 8-10, because it was a good book and educational, but chapter 8 really lost my attention until chapter 9.
Sincerely,
Shianne Salazar